PEACE Watch - Produced by the PEACE Mid-East Dialog Group

pleasign.gif (3087 bytes)

Contact/Join  Features 
Visit Jordan
       jsmall.gif (4629 bytes)

 

| Essay - Solving the Palestinian/Israeli Conflict |   Features

Previous Issues   Middle East Timeline  MewNews  MidEast Links       MidEastWebdialog   Books

Reseau du Moyen Orient en Français
Hebrew -  שער רשת המזרח התיכון לדו-קיום  Arabic MidEast Web - ابة شبكة الشّرق الأوسط بالعربيّة

Arab-English-Hebrew Dictionary    Israel in Cyberspace Israeli/ Jewish /Zionist Links

PeaceWatch Volume 8 #1
 February 11, 2006

FORWARD WITHOUT SHARON

02/10/2006

Upon first learning of Ariel Sharon's massive stroke, the BBC devoted most of its newscasts on PBS and NPR to this breaking story. Among the many personalities interviewed was Meretz party leader Dr. Yossi Beilin. I was amazed at the ignorance and naivete of the BBC newsman. Beilin, after being appropriately solicitous in expressing his concern for the health of the prime minister and the well-being of his family, shocked the interviewer by indicating that even in his recent role as the initiator of disengagement and withdrawal, Sharon was not a dove. The fact that Sharon never engaged the Palestinians in a genuine peace process seemed incredible to this so-called journalist.

Part of the legacy of Sharon's unilateralism is that Hamas was elected in the first place. I recall Amos Oz's caustic comment in 2001 that Sharon was "Arafat's gift" to the people of Israel, because Arafat's manipulation of violence is what undermined Barak and brought Sharon to power. In the same vein, Hamas is Sharon's "gift" to the Palestinians. This is not to excuse Arafat's legacy of cronyism, corruption and misrule. However, one could argue that the stage was set for the rise of Hamas when Sharon failed to bolster Abbas's political standing by releasing more prisoners and easing the lives of Palestinians. In any case, Palestinians suffering from severe restrictions on travel, losses of property, and settler violence and intimidation had had enough of Fatah's monopoly in power.

There's little doubt that if Sharon had remained in adequate health, he would have been elected at the head of his new Kadima (Forward) party as prime minister. He would also have likely made a significant unilateral withdrawal from the West Bank during his new term. However, given his enduring instincts as a warrior rather than a peacemaker, Sharon was probably only capable of unilateral initiatives.

Sharon's successors at the helm of Kadima are almost all more dovish. It was Ehud Olmert whose public statements first hinted at Sharon's new policy direction. This formerly right-wing Likudnik may have been decisively influenced by his wife, a member of Meretz. His influence may in turn have very well had a role in the limited but important change in Sharon. His major co-leader in Kadima is Tzipi Livni, now both foreign and justice minister, and similarly dovish. Additionally, there's the role of none other than Shimon Peres, now also among Kadima's leaders.

It is my hope ? not an expectation in these unsettled times and in such an inherently difficult neighborhood, but a real hope ? that Kadima will form a majority coalition with Labor and Meretz after the March 28 elections to lead Israel to a decidedly more peaceful and better future. Hamas may be a formidable obstacle to such hopes, but not necessarily.

I don't want to excuse any of the ongoing attacks (mostly rockets into the Negev), but Hamas has noticeably taken a terrorist back seat to Islamic Jihad since agreeing to a "lull" in the Intifada over half a year ago. Hamas is the most disciplined of all major Palestinian factions ? terrorist and otherwise. Hamas may even see it in its interest to stop attacks by Islamic Jihad, which has has rejected any suspension of the Intifada, and by unruly elements of Fatah and its most violent wing, the Al-Aksa Martyrs Brigades. Polling data tell us that even Hamas voters, like 70 percent of Palestinians in the territories, mostly back peace with Israel (although they have a funny way of showing this), having voted for Hamas as a protest against years of Fatah corruption and misrule ? one of Arafat's many "gifts" to his people. As in all Israeli elections, however, the risk of terrorist attack remains the wild card.

Ralph Seliger
 


RALPH SELIGER is editor of ISRAEL HORIZONS, the publication of Meretz USA. These views are his own.


Notice - This article is copyright by the author and MidEastWeb for Coexistence. Please forward it by email with a link to MidEastWeb Middle East Web Log http://www.mideastweb.org/log acknowledging the source. Other uses require permission.

This article also appears at http://www.mideastweb.org/log/archives/00000429.htm where you may comment.

Biography of Amir Peretz

Labor Zionism

Notice- Copyright

This article is Copyright © 2006 by  the author and Mideastweb for  Middle East Coexistence. . Please link to it and credit  Mideastweb for  Middle East Coexistence.  and  Ariga Peace Watch  Send it to friends by email with a link to http://www.ariga.com/peacewatch. Do not copy or syndicate this article in any other form without written permission..


Coming to Grips with Deir Yassin History of Zionism and the Creation of Israel

Comments about this article may be  sent to MidEastWeb  or to  our Web discussion forum.

Help Us Spread the Word

PLEASE LINK TO US AND CIRCULATE PEACEWATCH/MIDEASTWEB BY EMAIL

Be sure to give credit to PeaceWatch http://www.ariga.com/peacewatch and MidEastWeb - http://www.mideastweb.org

Mideastweb Middle East Gateway
Middle East Maps

Middle East Viewpoint Blog

Balanced History of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

Zionism

Israeli-Palestinian Middle East conflict in a nutshell

 

Jew, Jewish holy books, Judaism and the Talmud

Reseau du Moyen Orient en Français
Histoire du Israel, du Palestine et du conflit

Zionism and Peace at Zionism and Israel Information Center

                   Peace Child Israel - Education for Coexistence in the Middle East

e-mail subscription to PeaceWatch - MidEastWeb


Copyright

Copyright  © 2005  by the authors and by the PEACE group. MidEastWeb materials are copyright 2000 -2005 by MideastWeb for Coexistence  RA and are the protected intellectual property of the authors and MidEastWeb for Coexistence. They are subject to MidEastWeb copyright policy.   May be reproduced intact by e-mail only provided that credit is given to the authors, and to MideastWeb for Coexistence  RA http://www.mideastweb.org and the PEACE group, including addresses listed at the bottom.  You may not copy any material on this Web Site to your Web site, or reproduce it any form except e-mail without permission.  MideastWeb for Coexistence  materials are reproduced at PeaceWatch by permission.

 


 MewNews carries updated news both on the Web and by e-mail subscription  


Please send comments, problems, broken links etc. to


Opinions in PeaceWatch are those of the authors and do not represent PEACE or MidEastWeb policy.

PeaceWatch - other articles
Subscribe to the MEW e-dialog list

An objective history of the Deir Yassin Massacre

News and Views about Middle East News

Peacechild Israel - Teaching coexistence to Israeli and Palestinian Teens

News at MewNews

Reseau du Moyen Orient en Français
Histoire du Israel, du Palestine et du conflit


Middle East Dialog Resources 

Changing Sides - Arab and Jew present reversed opinions
on the future of Jerusalem

Peace Education at: http://www.mideastweb.org/education.htm

Also: Maps, Documents Books and more...

ZNN - Zionism News Network

What is PEACE?

PEACE is a Mid - East Dialog Group commited to peace and neighborly relations. We have no official political opinions. PEACE was started by Ameen Hannoun, a Jordanian/Palestinian and Ami Isseroff, an Israeli. You are welcome to join, and to contribute ariticles and ideas for promoting peace and dialog.  More about PEACE.  We are proud to be affiliated with MidEastWeb.

Mid-East News Service - In Depth Background on Regional Issues

Palestine-Israel-Zionism -History and Documents Additional documents at  Middle East History Pages of MidEast Web Middle East News Views History

and  Zionist source documents at Zionism and Israel Information Center

Background:

History of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

History of Zionism and the Creation of Israel (from a Zionist point of view)

Zionism - a history and brief definition

Israel-Palestina - (Dutch) Middle East Conflict, Israel, Palestine,Zionism... Israël-Palestina Informatie -gids Israël, Zionisme, Palestijnen en Midden-Oosten conflict...  (Mostly in Dutch)

Zionism-Israel Pages

Back to PEACEWATCH - Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Commentary and dialog

 

PEACE Features

Navigator - Click to go to Feature Topics & Contents

Please Join Us and Bring your Friends * Guest Columns Invited * Peace is up to you

Visitors since 11.12.98:

PEACE mailing list /Email Subscriptions
Comments

Postings should include these addresses:    
PEACEWatch: www.ariga.com/peacewatch/
PEACE:http://www.ariga.com/Dialog

MidEastWeb: http://www.mideastweb.org
PEACE POB 2493 Rehovot 76100, Israel

 

This Magazines Supporting Middle East Peace Process site owned by PEACE.
[ Previous 5 Sites | Previous | Next | Next 5 Sites | Random Site | List Sites ]


 

Ariga Publishing for Pleasure and Peace