PEACE Watch - Produced by the PEACE Mid-East Dialog Group

pleasign.gif (3087 bytes)

Contact/Join  Features 
Visit Jordan
       jsmall.gif (4629 bytes)

 

| Essay - Solving the Palestinian/Israeli Conflict |   Features

Previous Issues   Middle East Timeline  MewNews  MidEast Links       MidEastWebdialog   Books

Reseau du Moyen Orient en Français
Hebrew -  שער רשת המזרח התיכון לדו-קיום  Arabic MidEast Web - ابة شبكة الشّرق الأوسط بالعربيّة

Arab-English-Hebrew Dictionary    Israel in Cyberspace Israeli/ Jewish /Zionist Links

PeaceWatch Volume 7 #12
October 10, 2005

Abbas - Sharon summit postponed - No surprise there.

10/10/2005

The summit meeting between Israel PM Ariel Sharon and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas has been postponed, at least until Abbas returns from the USA. This was a wise and inevitable move, since they have nothing to discuss anyhow.


As noted previously in these pages, Abbas and Sharon are stuck in a kind of vaporlock due to pressures from extremists in their own camp, which are justified in turn by intransigence of the opposite side, which are due in turn to pressures from extremists. Sharon can't grant any concessions until Abbas disarms the Hamas. Abbas can't disarm the Hamas because he can't get Sharon to grant any concessions. The Israeli right points to the terror groups. Hamas points to the continued occupation and the prisoners in jail. Both Abbas and Sharon are before elections. Let's not kid ourselves. Both of them are surviving by the skin of their teeth and they know it. True, the Fatah won a big "victory" in the last election over the Hamas, but that election was in the West Bank, where Fatah is weak and didn't contest many of the local spots.

The summit, when it happens, isn't going to be about final status or Geneva accord or Palestinian recognition of Israel as a Jewish state or Right of Return. All those thorny issues we learn, have been laid aside. Since there must be negotiations, and there must be "progress" the sides have agreed on essentially harmless and meaningless concessions that they will demand from each other:
 


Commenting on the Palestinians' hopes for the summit, Erekat said they were seeking the release of 20 prisoners who have each spent more than 20 years in Israeli jails and an Israeli troop pullback from West Bank cities, beginning in Bethlehem.
...
According to a PA source, the Palestinian demands focus on four main points: the release of long-serving prisoners who were incarcerated before the Oslo Accords; the release of two "special" prisoners - an elderly detainee, and detainee suffering from a terminal illness; an arrangement that would allow the Church of the Nativity deportees to return to their homes in the West Bank; and the transfer of additional territory to the PA, with Ramallah and Hebron taking top priority.
 


So maybe there are two demands and maybe there are four. On the Israeli side, there is apparently a demand for a real crack-down on terror groups. We learn the following, according to the article:
 

 

Releasing 20 prisoners is not going to make peace between the Israelis and Palestinians. It isn't even a baby step in the right direction. Withdrawing from one or two cities won't help either, if history repeats itself. Within a week there will be a suicide bombing designed to torpedo the peace, and the cities will be reoccupied. Meanwhile, Israel will arrest 40 new prisoners in a security sweep, taking the place of the 20 that were released.

For his part, Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz is adamantly against supplying the Palestinians with arms and handing over security responsibility for additional West Bank cities in the near future. Mofaz believes the PA has yet to prove its commitment to combating terror. Without such action, Mofaz believes there is no justification for taking such risks at present.
 

Mofaz is against giving the Palestinians more arms, but the Palestinians didn't ask for more arms -- not publicly. It wouldn't do for Erekat to say they are asking Israel for weapons to use against the Hamas, would it?

Apparently, nobody wants these meetings except the Americans, because neither side is willing to bring anything to the table. The problem is solved by discussing what are essentially trivia, and then agreeing only to continue discussions about the discussions. Accordingly, committees were set up. This is a sure sign that nothing real is going to happen. An Israel Prime Minister's Office press release announces: "Joint Israeli-Palestinian Statement on Establishment of Joint Committees." According to the announcement "It was agreed that after PA Chairman Abu Mazen returns from Washington, the two leaders would meet in order to evaluate the committees' progress." Presumably, they will agree to meet in order to discuss establishing more committees to monitor the committees.

Read it and weep.

Ami Isseroff
 

This article also appears here   at the MidEastWeb Middle East Web Log  where you can comment


PS - About Internet insanity - What is "Googletestad?" Find out here -
Googletestad -
http://www.zionism-israel.com/googletestad.htm


Googletestad -
http://www.zionism-israel.com/googletestad.htm

Coming to Grips with Deir Yassin History of Zionism and the Creation of Israel

Comments about this article may be  sent to MidEastWeb  or to  our Web discussion forum.

Help Us Spread the Word

PLEASE LINK TO US AND CIRCULATE PEACEWATCH/MIDEASTWEB BY EMAIL

Be sure to give credit to PeaceWatch http://www.ariga.com/peacewatch and MidEastWeb - http://www.mideastweb.org

Mideastweb Middle East Gateway
Middle East Maps

Middle East Viewpoint Blog

Balanced History of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

Zionism

Israeli-Palestinian Middle East conflict in a nutshell

 

Jew, Jewish holy books, Judaism and the Talmud

Reseau du Moyen Orient en Français
Histoire du Israel, du Palestine et du conflit

Zionism and Peace at Zionism and Israel Information Center

                   Peace Child Israel - Education for Coexistence in the Middle East

e-mail subscription to PeaceWatch - MidEastWeb


Copyright

Copyright 2004   by the author, by MidEastWeb for Coexistence and by the PEACE group. May be reproduced intact by e-mail only provided that credit is given to the authors, and to MideastWeb for Coexistence RA and the PEACE group, including addresses listed at the bottom.  You may not copy any material on this Web Site to your Web site, or reproduce it any form except e-mail without permission.  


 MewNews carries updated news both on the Web and by e-mail subscription  


Please send comments, problems, broken links etc. to


Opinions in PeaceWatch are those of the authors and do not represent PEACE or MidEastWeb policy.

PeaceWatch - other articles
Subscribe to the MEW e-dialog list

An objective history of the Deir Yassin Massacre

News and Views about Middle East News

Peacechild Israel - Teaching coexistence to Israeli and Palestinian Teens

News at MewNews

Reseau du Moyen Orient en Français
Histoire du Israel, du Palestine et du conflit


Middle East Dialog Resources 

Changing Sides - Arab and Jew present reversed opinions
on the future of Jerusalem

Peace Education at: http://www.mideastweb.org/education.htm

Also: Maps, Documents Books and more...

What is PEACE?

PEACE is a Mid - East Dialog Group commited to peace and neighborly relations. We have no official political opinions. PEACE was started by Ameen Hannoun, a Jordanian/Palestinian and Ami Isseroff, an Israeli. You are welcome to join, and to contribute ariticles and ideas for promoting peace and dialog.  More about PEACE.  We are proud to be affiliated with MidEastWeb.

Mid-East News Service - In Depth Background on Regional Issues

 

PEACE Features

Navigator - Click to go to Feature Topics & Contents

Please Join Us and Bring your Friends * Guest Columns Invited * Peace is up to you

Visitors since 11.12.98:

PEACE mailing list /Email Subscriptions
Comments

Postings should include these addresses:    
PEACEWatch: www.ariga.com/peacewatch/
PEACE:http://www.ariga.com/Dialog

MidEastWeb: http://www.mideastweb.org
PEACE POB 2493 Rehovot 76100, Israel

 

This Magazines Supporting Middle East Peace Process site owned by PEACE.
[ Previous 5 Sites | Previous | Next | Next 5 Sites | Random Site | List Sites ]


 

Ariga Publishing for Pleasure and Peace