Search Amazon:
In Association with Amazon.com
Google

Web Ariga
About
Contact
Donations
Middle East NewsToday's
Situation
News
Peace PoliticsEducational
Resources
for Peace
Pleasure - arts and letters Pleasure:
Arts
& Letters

Get Today's Situation by Robert Rosenberg, Monday-Friday Subscribe Unsubscribe

AOL users, please note -- due to anti-spam measures by AOL, you sometimes do not receive your update. Please inform abuse@aol.com that Ariga mail is not spam.

Tears and scuffles, Wednesday, August 17, 2005

Updated 21:00

The language of the disengagement procedures this morning was decidedly military – ‘Southern Gush Katif has collapsed, northern Gaza has been vanquished,’ was typical of the reportage describing the emptying settlements – but the procedure was far from the all-out violence that has been anticipated for months. True, there were scuffles, pushing and shoving, taunting and harangues. Garbage bins were set on fire, individual protestors who turned particularly unruly were carted off by four troopers, whether police or army. And in the West Bank, at a Shiloh industrial zone, just what the security services feared took place -- a Jewish terrorist killed three Palestinians, telling police who captured him that he was trying to stop the disengagement.

But as of noon today, the authorities appeared determined to avoid the kind of full-front clash that the protestors have been promising was inevitable if the troops moved in to remove them from the settlements. Thus, for every minor clash with protestors trying to block troops from reaching the homes of Neve Dekalim, considered the ‘capital’ of Gush Katif, there was a scene of cloyingly bathetic weeping by protestors embracing obviously embarrassed policemen or soldiers who were under strict orders to be empathetic, even if only moments before the protestor had been haranguing the trooper as doomed for God’s wrath for all eternity for daring to replicate what ‘the goyim did to Jews, not what Jews do to Jews.’

By noon, northern Gaza’s settlements were empty, southern Gush Katif was almost empty as it was being voluntarily evacuated by its residents, and the main focus was on Neve Dekalim, Kfar Darom, and Netzarim, the three main settlements of Gaza, and Shirat Hayam, where Kahanist-style radicals have been building a ‘tent city’ and preparing for a showdown with the authorities. Netzarim and Kfar Darom were apparently being held for last – they are inhabited by the most hardcore of the settler extremists. So, Neve Dekalim, as the capital, was the strategic goal for the security forces. If it could ‘fall,’ as the military analysts said, the rest of the Gush will fall. According to Uri Bar Lev, the Southern Police District Commander, all the illegal infiltrators who had roamed Neve Dekalim in a cat and mouse game with the authorities, had been rounded up and put on buses for expulsion to the detention centers set up for the purpose. Now, he told the press, ‘we are going from house to house, speaking to the residents. True, the images are difficult, people having to leave their homes of 20 or 30 years, but that is the mission and we must do it.’ As each settlement empties, the army occupied it to make sure none of the protestors slip in to resume resistance and to prevent looting.

It is evident that the evacuation will be, after all, much easier than predicted. The army is already talking about finishing the work in Gaza by the weekend, and early next week moving in on Sa-Nur and Homesh, the two remaining settlements south of Jenin that over the last few months were occupied by some of the most radical elements in the settlement movement. That accelerated schedule means that the entire operation, including the demolition of the buildings, could be over by mid-September, instead of October-November, as originally scheduled.

While the Israelis focused on the scenes from Gush Katif, with cameras seeming to take part in the ‘dialogue’ between the commanding officers on the ground and the local leadership, whether of the teenage gangs from the West Bank or the local residents, the Palestinians meanwhile were under pressure to maintain the quiet that has so far prevailed since the evacuation began on Monday. Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas met yesterday with Assistant Secretary of State for Near Eastern Affairs David Welch and Lt. Gen William Ward, and overnight, Abbas was said to have received phone calls from Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and a messages from British Prime Minister Tony Blair. At least according to the Israeli reports, the message to Abbas was that if the Palestinians keep the quiet, they can expect more progress down the road.

But the Israelis of course are very skeptical about the Palestinians. Military Intelligence Commander Aharon Zeevi Farkash told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee yesterday afternoon that if the Palestinians don’t see progress in the West Bank and Jerusalem by next spring, a new wave of terror against Israel can be expected. Perhaps. It is however certain that the international community will be pressing the sides to turn the Gaza withdrawal into Israeli-Palestinian dialogue after the withdrawal is over. Trouble is, the conventional wisdom nowadays in Israel, from Labor on the Left to Likud on the Right, is that despite all his good intentions, Mahmoud Abbas and his Palestinian Authority is no partner for political dialogue.

At most, there can be some modicum of security cooperation, on specific issues – like the disengagement procedure, which includes joint Israeli-Palestinian military cooperation specifically meant to deal with any untoward incidents that arise. Those could be either a Palestinian rocket attack on the settlements where thousands of troops and hundreds of settlers and protestors are crowded around the synagogues that are turning into the bastions for the protests – or no less dangerous, a shooting attack by settler protestors on the nearby Palestinian neighborhoods as a provocation. Just such a shooting took place at Shiloh, when a 40-year-old man from Shvut Rachel, a tiny settlement near Shiloh, killed three Palestinian workers whom he knew well -- his job was to drive them to and from work at an alumimium company in the Shiloh industrial zone. The shooting raised worries about Palestinian retaliation, promised by Hamas. Chief of Staff Dan Halutz, appearing on Channel Two said that he had 'hope the Palestinians understand that just as they have difficult controlling their extremists, we have trouble with ours.' It was an extraordinary admission by an IDF chief of staff, considering Israeli policy toward the Palestinians has been predicated on the supposition that the Palestinians never will do enough to restrain their radicals.

Indeed, for all the optimism about the pace of the evacuation, and even if Neve Dekalim ‘falls’ today, Netzarim and Kfar Darom remain as hotbeds of determined opposition to the withdrawal – so much so that even today, settlers in both places were refusing to pack their belongings, watering their gardens, going through the motions of their routines. The authorities will indeed need sensitivity – but also a lot of determination – to deal with the clearly deluded people of those two settlements, where the residents are still saying they have no intention of leaving their homes.

More news from today || Yesterday's situation (Archive)

© Today's Situation From Ariga, http://www.ariga.com by Robert Rosenberg; Feel free to pass this page on, including this line: Subscribe to get it daily by email -- or unsubscribe -- at http://www.ariga.com/signup.shtml >>>>>>>>>>RSS Feed

Feed Shark

Today's Situation || Yesterday's Situation

Today's Situation from Ariga is written Monday-Friday at midday by simon spungin in Tel Aviv and updated exclusively for subscribers at night. It's free to subscribe, but donations are, of course, welcome <g>
Subscribe
Unsubscribe

If this page was helpful, please consider making a small donation to keep Ariga going.
It's easy, and safe, through Paypal.

Back to the top
Using Amazon or Google links from this page to do your online shopping and searching is another way to help Ariga.

Visit one of the subject areas for the books interest Ariga visitors: Yiddish || Middle East Affairs || Military Affairs || Religion || Hippotherapy (Horses and Feldenkrais) || Women's Issues || Pop Culture || Cooking || American Issues || Amazon's Top 100 Best Sellers

Sponsored links: North Cyprus Properties || Software Development


© Ariga 1995-2005. For republishing rights please contact the author of the specific article on this page. Permission is granted to link to this page.

Ariga: Today's Situation, 2006
Ariga: Today's Situation, 2005
Ariga: Today's Situation, 2004
Ariga: Today's Situation, 2003
Ariga Monthly: 1997-2002

Painting
by Silvia Rosenberg
Goddess Loves Women
Goddess Loves Women, from the Goddess series

Please check out our Google advertisers


The Israeli-Palestinian peace radio station



Make a donation to Ariga



The People's Voice Petition for Peace for Israel and Palestine

Don't miss:

The MidEastweb for Coexistence

horse logo
Horses and Feldenkrais in the West Jerusalem Hills
(Workshops in Hebrew and English